I was asked by Ric, before putting hand to the BAD, to wrote down a bit what i was going to change/update/keep. I came up with that proposal (were K reads "keep", U "update" & A "add"). Please let me know any suggestion/doubt/question/comment about that proposal: I'm going to wait a bit more before updating-committing tex files :) !!! Sorry about the long email and thanks for your help. Cheers, ale ######################################## Proposed updates to the BAD: 2.2) MC samples K-> Keep generic and cocktail description A-> Add description of SP4 run1 and run2 differences and Ks bug K-> Keep signal MC description (newly added MC needs documentation form Concezio) U-> Redo plots in figure 3 (with all new-old MC) K-> Keep nonreso and hybrid description U-> Update table 3 with new numbers 3.7) Data-MC comparison U-> Review the statement about cocktail and generic role in measurement (now we'll have a lot of generic too) U-> Redo plots in figures 27-33. (phot7,trk7,ksfix2 from Urs) A-> I propose to add at that point the breakdown btw B,B0 and B+ and to store all the plots in the appendix. (shall we need Q0, Q1, Q2??) U-> Comments: (those will be done after a final discussion on last selection). However here are few major points: 1) Keep comments about pcms (e-m) 2) Trk and Neu multiplicty are showing problems (can we say here few words about splitoffs,loopers??) 3) mm2 still showing problems (mainly due to K0,neut: do we want to put down that statement?) 4) mxhadfit: agreement is quite good 5) Qtot: still having problems (mention how sys are taking care of that? mention Dsys role?) 6) Eneut: decent agreement... A-> Comment on general disagreement btw B0 and B+: we state that sys are going to take care of that discrepancy U-> Redo plots for mm2 (keep them in bulk of BAD not appendix). (fig 35-36) A-> Add in bulk of BAD same plots (as 35-36) for Mx and Qtot (crucial quantities) 6.5) Bkg composition U-> Redo Guglielmo study (Am I in charge of that??? Probably yes) ######################################## ______________________________________________________ Alessio Sarti Universita' & I.N.F.N. Ferrara tel +39-0532-781928 Ferrara roma +39-06-49914338 SLAC +001-650-926-2972 "... e a un Dio 'fatti il culo' non credere mai..." (F. De Andre') "He was turning over in his mind an intresting new concept in Thau-dimensional physics which unified time, space, magnetism, gravity and, for some reason, broccoli". (T. Pratchett: "Pyramids") On Fri, 4 Oct 2002, Riccardo Faccini wrote: > Hi, > in order to be able to go back to the review process as soon as we have > some results, I would suggest we start a review of the content of the BAD > (while waiting for jobs, dead afs cells etc etc ..)... > > Here is the list of chapters to be updated and the person who could take > care of it. Please correct me if it is incorrect. [P.S. I refer to the > BAD as tagged today as rf-100402] > 2.1 Urs > 2.2 Alessio > 3.1 Ric (with material from Urs) > 3.2.2 Ric > 3.3 Ric > 3.4 Ric > 3.6 Daniele > 3.7 Urs/Alessio > 5.X Daniele > 6.X Ric (one more pass in general ...) > 6.2.1 daniele > 6.5 Alessio > > ciao ciao > ric > > > >