 |
 |
No objections from me. BTW I am on vacation so my responses will be sporadic until next week. Andy On Mon, 27 Sep 2010, Gerardo Ganis wrote: > Hi Andreas, > > Thanks. I have found a couple of modules which need to add XrdSys in the linking list ... I also do not see other problems so far. > > If nobody objects (Andy?) I will commit the tiny changes so that we can have ALICE importing a new tarball and start testing ... > > Cheers, Gerri > > On Sep 27, 2010, at 1:56 PM, Andreas-Joachim Peters <[log in to unmask]> wrote: > >> Yes, >> also 'my' problem came via the ALICE build system .... >> >> I tried and it seems there is no obvious problem coming out of it. But I didn't test every existing plugin! >> >> Cheers Andreas. >> >> >> On Mon, Sep 27, 2010 at 1:40 PM, Gerardo Ganis <[log in to unmask]> wrote: >> >> Hi, >> >> Suddendly this seems an issue also for ALICE now. >> I am doing some tests removing the XrdSys... from XrdOuc. >> Andreas, did you already try? >> >> Gerri >> >> >> >> >> On 09/23/2010 09:39 PM, Andrew Hanushevsky wrote: >>> >>> Hi Andreas, >>> >>> Looking at the GNUmakefile for XrdOuc it's obvious that XrdSysLogger is improperly included in that build. A bug, obviously. So, easy to correct. If you can, simply fix the GNUmakefile for XrdOuc to remove that file from the list and rebuild. I suspect that there may be instance where someone relied on this (bad) behaviour so there XrdSys.a will need to be added. Let me know how you want to proceed. >>> >>> Andy >>> ----- Original Message ----- >>> From: Andreas-Joachim Peters >>> To: xrootd-dev >>> Sent: Thursday, September 23, 2010 5:20 AM >>> Subject: xrootd protocol 'classic build' static library overlaps >>> >>> I face the following problem with the static library structure in the head using the classic build: >>> >>> nm /tmp/classic/lib/libXrdSys.a | grep _ZN12XrdSysLoggerC1Eii >>> 0000000000000930 T _ZN12XrdSysLoggerC1Eii >>> >>> nm /tmp/classic/lib/libXrdOuc.a | grep _ZN12XrdSysLoggerC1Eii >>> 0000000000000930 T _ZN12XrdSysLoggerC1Eii >>> >>> nm /tmp/classic/lib/libXrdSys.a | grep strlcpy >>> 0000000000000000 T strlcpy >>> >>> nm /tmp/classic/lib/libXrdOuc.a | grep strlcpy >>> U strlcpy >>> >>> >>> As in this example: if I need some function using strlcpy I need to link XrdOuc & XrdSys, but both libraries are only as static available ( XrdOuc links some objects from XrdSys in but not all!) and I get double defined symbols (on MAC). What can we do here? >>> >>> Cheers Andreas. >> >> >